Former gum merchant Scott Schiaffo returns for the worst of March 1976, 1983 & 1994!
Episode page
Keith Coogan and his toy soldiers March back for the week experience 1979, 1988 & 1998!
Episode page
Tee off with Joel Murray in this battle between March 1977, 1987 & 1997!
Episode page
Mike Ranger gets all achy breaky over the worst of February 1975, 1982 & 1993!
Episode page
The team behind the Nickelodeon documentary The Orange Years returns to judge the stupid criminals of 1974, 1980 & 1998!
Episode page
Robert Tepper returns to judge this birthday battle between 1978, 1984 & 1995!
Episode page
Wax returns with a vengeance to adjudicate this battle between 1976, 1985 & 1992!
Episode page
Bum Wine Bob is behind the bench for this bodacious booze battle between 1971, 1981 & 1991!
Episode page
Mike Ranger returns to rule over this retro rumble between 1979, 1987 & 1996!
Episode page
You're favorite Chewlies Gum rep, Scott Schiaffo of Clerks judges this battle between 1977, 1988 & 1999!
Episode page
The Last Blockbuster director Taylor Morden judges this B-movie battle between 1985, 1990 & 1995!
Episode page
The phantom phreak himself Renoly Santiago picks the worst of 1975, 1989 & 1997!
Episode page
Chris Van Vliet renders his verdict on this wrestling duel between 1984, 1992 & 1999!
Episode page
Have you seen this man? It's the battle of December between 1978, 1982 & 1990!
Episode page
James Duval goes Beast Mode on December 1976, 1986 & 1996 in this retro rumble!
Episode page
Chris Ballew from The Presidents of the United States of America picks the best peaches from 1973, 1981 & 1992!
Episode page
The Leader of the Monster Squad, Andre Gower determines if 1979, 1985 or 1998 had the finest Nards!
Episode page
Master impressionist Jim Meskimen judges this duel between 1974, 1984 & 1994!
Episode page
The Creators of the new Nickelodeon documentary The Orange Years slime 1977, 1988 & 1997!
Episode page
Mike Ranger returns to make a ruling on who had the best week between October 1975, 1982, & 1993!
Episode page
A night at the Hotel Coral Essex with Wormser and the best of 1978, 1983 & 1995!
Episode page
Ajay Popoff of Lit judges this worst of battle between 76, 87 & 99 guaranteed to make you completely miserable
Episode page
Be prepared to lose your mind, it's movies Jay has never seen.
Episode page
Another retro sit-down with the man who isn't even supposed to be here today, Brian O'Halloran
Episode page
